A U.S. judge on Tuesday rejected a proposed $18.9 million civil settlement for women who claimed they were subjected to sexual abuse and workplace harassment by the disgraced movie producer Harvey Weinstein.
U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein in Manhattan said the preliminary settlement would be unfair to women who Weinstein raped or sexually abused, because it treated them no different from women who had merely met him.
He also criticized a plan to set aside money to help Weinstein and the board of his former studio pay defense costs. “The idea that Harvey Weinstein could get a defense fund ahead of the plaintiffs is obnoxious,” Hellerstein said at a hearing.
A settlement would have resolved class-action litigation by Weinstein accusers, and New York Attorney General Letitia James’ lawsuit accusing Weinstein, his brother Bob Weinstein and their bankrupt Weinstein Co of maintaining a hostile work environment.
Elizabeth Fegan, a lawyer representing nine Weinstein accusers, had argued that “all of the women were in the zone of danger” created by Weinstein, justifying class-action treatment.
Lawyers for the settling plaintiffs and for Weinstein did not immediately respond to requests for comment. A lawyer for Weinstein Co declined to comment.
James’ office will review the decision. “Our office has been fighting tirelessly to provide these brave women with the justice they are owed and will continue,” a spokeswoman said.
The settlement drew objections from women who said it would leave Weinstein’s victims with typical awards of just $10,000 to $20,000, while setting aside $15.2 million for defense costs.
Douglas Wigdor, a lawyer representing six objectors, said he was pleased Hellerstein “swiftly rejected the one-sided proposal.”
Weinstein, 68, is appealing his February 24 conviction and 23-year prison term for sexually assaulting a former production assistant and raping a onetime aspiring actress. He still faces separate rape and sexual assault charges in Los Angeles.
- Harvey Weinstein Is a Convicted Rapist. What’s Next?
- Harvey Weinstein & Disney Hit With Underage Rape Lawsuit; Four Jane Does Allege Assaults By Convicted Producer
- Four more Harvey Weinstein accusers come forward including one who was 17 ‘when the vile half-naked mogul raped her’
- Harvey Weinstein’s Extradition to L.A. Is Delayed Because of COVID-19
- The vote-by-mail cases that could decide the 2020 election
- Bob Hawke’s daughter Rosslyn Dillon settles multi-million dollar claim against his will
- Claims of Sex Addiction Don’t Save Weinstein
- Changeling actor John Malkovich, 66, reveals was hit on by a male professor, 50, when he was 19 adding Bernie Madoff stole 'millions' from him
- REVEALED: Facebook's new 'great and good' privacy committee created as part of $5B settlement with US government following Cambridge Analytica scandal
- FCC Releases More Info On $48 Million Fine To Sinclair Broadcast Group; Democrats Blast It As An Insufficient Settlement
- Roundups: Kingwood’s S&A Nails reopens in May for the first time after Harvey
- Proposed Settlement Of Least $25 To Owners Of Apple iPhones With Slowed Performance Moves Forward
- BART, Oscar Grant's mother settle: $1.3 million
- Fiserv's First Data pays $40 million to settle FTC charges it aided merchants' fraud
- Covid-19 cases concerning prisoners' rights hit the Supreme Court
- Remember ‘Who Am I to Judge’? Vatican Silent on France’s Gay Appointee
- Missouri Man Gets $8 Million Settlement After Serving 17 Years Behind Bars for Murder He Didn't Commit
- ICC rejects compensation claim by former Congo VP Bemba
- EXCLUSIVE: Is Ghislaine Maxwell hiding out at Jeffrey Epstein's Zorro Ranch? New court docs reveal she's requesting Annie Farmer's civil case be moved to New Mexico where the 16-year-old 'was sexually assaulted'
- BART pays $1.5 million to aid Grant's daughter
Harvey Weinstein case: U.S. judge rejects $18.9 million civil settlement have 579 words, post on www.thehindu.com at July 15, 2020. This is cached page on Game Breaking News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.